I recently learned about an antique wiring method called "knob and tube" that could be a fire hazard in older homes. As a homeowner, I wanted to understand the risks so I could protect my family and property. Here's what I discovered about this strange and dangerous practice:
What Is Knob and Tube Wiring?
Knob and tube wiring was commonly installed in homes built before 1940. It gets its name from the knobs that hold the wires apart and the tubes that protect wires through framing members.
This type of wiring consists of:
- Individual wires running through the walls, attic, and crawlspaces. Wires are separated by porcelain knobs and run through porcelain tubes where they pass through walls and floors.
- No ground wire. Knob and tube circuits were not grounded, which is a safety hazard.
- Cloth insulation on wires instead of plastic. The old cloth insulation is prone to deterioration over time.
The key problems with knob and tube wiring are the lack of a ground wire and the deterioration of the insulation over many decades. This can lead to fire risks.
Why Knob and Tube Wiring Is Dangerous
There are several reasons why knob and tube wiring presents safety issues in older homes:
-
Fire hazard - The worn cloth insulation leaves wires exposed, which can spark and catch fire in the walls. This can easily spread undetected.
-
Shocks and electrocution risks - There is no ground wire, so if a wire is damaged or something shorts the circuit, you could get shocked or electrocuted.
-
Overloading circuits - The wiring is insufficient for handling heavier loads from modern appliances and electronics. Overloads can overheat wires and start fires.
-
Difficult to inspect - It runs through inaccessible areas like walls and attics, making it hard to inspect the condition of the wiring. Any problems are out of sight.
-
Insurance issues - Many insurance companies won't issue policies for homes with knob and tube wiring due to the substantial risks.
I spoke with a few local electricians who confirmed they consider knob and tube wiring a serious fire hazard and won't do any work on it except full replacement.
Signs You May Have Knob and Tube Wiring
Here are some signs that a home may have original knob and tube wiring:
-
Two-prong outlets - No ground pin since there is no ground wire.
-
Wall cavities with knobs - You may see ceramic knobs inside unfinished walls or attics.
-
Black cloth wiring - The old black cloth insulation is an obvious sign.
-
Fuses not breakers - Fuse boxes indicate old wiring.
-
Lack of visible ground wires - If you don't see ground wires with the other wiring, it's likely knob and tube.
I checked my basement and attic and unfortunately found knobs, tubes, and cloth wiring confirming my house still has its original hazardous wiring.
Dangers and Risks of Keeping Knob and Tube Wiring
Here are some of the biggest risks my family faces by keeping the antiquated knob and tube wiring:
-
Fire breaking out - This is by far the most serious risk. The older insulation and lack of modern safety features make fires much more likely over time. Fires sparked by faulty wiring can rage out of control.
-
Shocks or electrocution - Without a proper ground wire, a short could electrify metal surfaces and injure or kill someone. I have small children, so this is particularly concerning.
-
Reliability issues - We've had occasional flickering lights and odd electrical behavior indicating problems with the old wiring. As it further deteriorates, more issues will arise.
-
Damage to appliances - Voltage spikes caused by overloads on the wiring can fry televisions, computers, and other electronics.
-
Decrease in home value - Knob and tube wiring makes a house difficult to insure and sell. We'd likely have to sell at a substantial discount.
The more I learn about knob and tube wiring, the more anxious I become about the safety of my family. The risk of an electrical fire is unacceptably high.
Safer Alternatives to Knob and Tube Wiring
The only truly safe options involve completely replacing the old wiring:
-
Full rewire - Removing all knob and tube wiring and installing new wiring to modern code. This can be expensive but is the most thorough solution.
-
Pigtailing - Attaching new wires to old and capping old wires. This isolates old wires but doesn't remove them.
-
Circuit breakers - Upgrading the fuse box to circuit breakers improves safety. However, the rest of the wiring is still hazardous.
I plan to have my entire house rewired to eliminate all traces of knob and tube wiring. Though costly, protecting my family from fire is well worth the investment. I urge other homeowners to take steps to address this strange, outdated wiring method before disaster strikes. Don't take chances with potentially deadly knob and tube wiring lurking in your walls.