I live in an old house built in the 1920s. When I first moved in, I was unaware of the antiquated electrical system hidden inside the walls. Upon inspection, I discovered that the wiring was an obsolete 'knob and tube' system, which can pose serious fire and shock hazards in vintage homes. This prompted me to research this perilous method of wiring which still exists in millions of older dwellings across North America.
What is Knob and Tube Wiring?
Knob and tube (K&T) is an early standardized method of electrical wiring used in buildings from about 1880 to the 1940s. It consists of insulated copper conductors passing through ceramic knobs mounted on wooden framing and interconnected by porcelain tubes.
Some key features of knob and tube wiring:
- Two separate wires - one for hot and one for neutral
- No ground wire
- Wires separated from each other and building materials using air as an insulator
- Porcelain knobs, tubes, and cleats used to route and support wires
- Wires are often coated with cloth or rubber insulation
This old-fashioned wiring system was phased out in favor of safer and more efficient systems using electrical cables and conduits. However, K&T wiring still exists in many old homes constructed prior to 1950.
Why Knob and Tube Wiring is Dangerous
There are several factors that make knob and tube wiring potentially unsafe:
- No grounding - Lack of a ground wire means there is no path to safely divert electrical surges or lightning strikes away from equipment. This can lead to shocks.
- Insulation deteriorates - The original cloth or rubber insulation often breaks down over time, exposing bare wires that can spark and ignite fires.
- Not designed for modern loads - These systems were designed for lower electrical loads. Connecting high-wattage appliances can lead to overheating.
- Haphazard modifications - DIY tampering and improper splicing into old K&T wiring can compromise safety.
- Concealed fire risks - Hidden wire damage and connections go unnoticed within walls and can smolder for long periods before a fire erupts.
For these reasons, insurance providers often will not cover houses with knob and tube wiring or require upgrades prior to issuing policies.
Where Does Knob and Tube Wiring Linger Today?
I was surprised to discover how common knob and tube wiring still is. Here are some facts about where it persists today:
- Old houses - Any home built before 1950 likely contains some amount of K&T wiring, especially in older cities. Up to 25 million dwellings in the US and Canada still have it.
- Walls, attics, and basements - The wiring often hides unseen until renovations and can run through structural framing and joists.
- Under floors - K&T wiring may be buried under layers of flooring or tucked inside crawl spaces. Out of sight, out of mind.
- Behind walls - When walls are covered in plaster or drywall, hazards go undetected. Signs like cracking or discoloration around outlets can indicate issues.
- Insulated over - Some homeowners have concealed old K&T wiring by installing insulation over it. This does not alleviate fire risks.
Unless properly updated, any older home should be presumed to contain some obsolete and possibly compromised K&T circuits.
Is Knob and Tube Wiring Ever Acceptable to Leave In Place?
Some homeowners may be tempted to just leave vintage knob and tube wiring alone. However, there are very few cases where K&T can be safely maintained:
- Low-voltage circuits for doorbells and millwork may be tolerated.
- If wiring was unusually overbuilt and shows no deterioration, upgrades are still recommended.
- Where wiring is accessible and individual circuits can be thoroughly inspected and repaired.
- As a temporary measure while home wiring is systematically upgraded over time.
Otherwise, a full replacement of old knob and tube wiring is the only prudent option in most homes. Leaving damaged, overloaded, or concealed K&T in place indefinitely is asking for trouble down the line.
Signs Your Home May Still Have Hidden Knob and Tube Wiring:
- Two-prong outlets - Lack of ground on receptacles often indicates K&T circuits.
- Blowing fuses - Overloaded old wiring can cause frequent fuse blowing.
- Dimming lights - If lights dim noticeably when appliances turn on, wiring is suspect.
- Older electrical panels - Early fuse boxes and insufficient capacity can mean antiquated wiring lurks behind walls.
- Scorch marks or cracking around outlets - Can signal overheated wires.
- Insufficient circuits - Not enough separate circuits for a house of its size.
- Unsafe DIY splices - Shoddy connections made outside of junction boxes.
If in doubt, consult with a qualified electrician to identify if your vintage home still harbors any knob and tube wiring. Stay vigilant for any indications of old wiring as a fire prevention measure.
Options for Replacing Knob and Tube Wiring:
-
Full rewire - The most thorough option is to completely remove old wiring and install brand new modern wiring throughout the home. This allows incorporating safety features like grounding and GFCI outlets.
-
Targeted upgrades - For budget reasons, some homeowners opt to only replace K&T wiring in the most hazardous or highest load locations. Prioritize kitchens, bathrooms, and laundry first.
-
Wiring insulation - Special plastic sleeves can be installed over K&T wires as an interim protective measure. But this does not alleviate all risks.
-
Circuit breakers - Upgrading outdated fuse boxes to modern circuit breaker panels can add capacity and safety to old wiring.
No matter the approach, it is wise for homeowners to be proactive about addressing vintage electrical systems. Replacing antiquated knob and tube wiring removes accrued dangers that come with improperly maintained older homes.
Conclusion:
Knob and tube wiring has not disappeared entirely. In fact, it still lurks unseen in millions of North American homes over 70 years old. While convenient and innovative in its heyday, K&T wiring now poses unacceptable fire and shock risks due to deterioration and lack of grounding. Homeowners should be vigilant for signs of old wiring and work to upgrade or replace any existing knob and tube circuits. Although costly, a full rewiring is the safest long-term solution for vintage dwellings still relying on this obsolete and hazardous electrical system. With vigilance and proactive upgrades, the lingering dangers of old knob and tube wiring can be eliminated.