What is Knob and Tube Wiring?
Knob and tube wiring was an early standardized method of electrical wiring used in buildings in the United States from about 1880 to the 1940s. It consists of insulated copper conductors passing through ceramic knobs and tubes, which provide protection and structural support.
The knobs separate the wires to prevent contact between them, while the tubes protect wires where they pass through framing members. This old wiring system did not include a ground wire, relying on the air between conductors as insulation.
The Rise and Fall of Knob and Tube Wiring
Knob and tube wiring became popular as electricity spread through cities in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. It was an inexpensive and straightforward way to add electrical wiring during a time of rapid development and expansion.
By the 1920s and 1930s, knob and tube wiring was the standard wiring method used for lighting and power in most homes and commercial buildings. However, it started to decline in the 1930s and 40s as newer and safer wiring methods emerged, like non-metallic sheathed cable and concealed armored cable.
Dangers and Downsides of Knob and Tube Wiring
While knob and tube wiring met the needs of the early electrical era, it has some significant drawbacks and dangers:
-
No ground wire - This older system does not include a ground wire, which is essential for safety. Ungrounded systems can lead to shocks and electrocution hazards.
-
Fire risk - The insulation on old wiring deteriorates over time, exposing bare wires that can arc and spark, igniting nearby combustible materials. Knob and tube wires are often run through unfinished walls and attics with wood framing.
-
Insufficient for modern loads - Knob and tube wiring was only designed to handle light loads. Today's high-wattage appliances can be unsafe on these outdated electrical systems.
-
Insurance issues - Many insurance companies refuse to insure homes with knob and tube wiring due to the substantial risks. This can make buying or selling a home very difficult.
Why Knob and Tube Wiring Remains in Many Homes
Despite the risks, it is estimated that millions of older homes across the United States still have original knob and tube wiring. Here are some key reasons this obsolete wiring lingers today:
-
Lack of awareness - Some homeowners do not realize their home has knob and tube wiring, especially if it is hidden behind walls and ceilings. Finding it often requires an inspection by a qualified electrician.
-
Grandfathered in - In many areas, knob and tube wiring is technically "grandfathered" in and does not have to be updated to meet current code unless major renovations are done.
-
Cost to replace - Re-wiring an entire home with modern wiring is extremely expensive, often costing between $8,000-$15,000. Many homeowners cannot afford such a large cost.
-
Piecemeal repairs - Instead of complete re-wiring, some homeowners try to patch knob and tube wiring or run new wiring alongside it. However, this does not eliminate the root dangers.
Dangers to Consider If Your Home Still Has Knob and Tube
Here are some specific risks to weigh if your home still relies on aging and hazardous knob and tube wiring:
-
Fire - As insulation breaks down over time, exposed live wires can arc, spark, and ignite fires in walls and attics. Replacing knob and tube wiring reduces this serious fire hazard.
-
Shocks and electrocution - Faulty wiring leads to greater risks of electrical shocks, especially for children. Also, lack of grounding raises chances of fatal electrocutions.
-
Appliance hazards - Modern high-wattage appliances like refrigerators, microwaves, and air conditioners can overload old knob and tube circuits and cause fires.
-
Insurance limitations - Homeowners insurance providers like State Farm and Allstate often decline coverage for homes with knob and tube wiring, due to fire risks.
-
Re-sale difficulties - Houses with knob and tube wiring are very difficult to sell and have greatly reduced market values, because buyers cannot get financing.
Weighing Your Repair Options
If you discover your home has original knob and tube electrical wiring, here are some repair options to consider:
-
Full rewire - Though expensive, this is the only way to completely remove fire and shock hazards by replacing all old wiring.
-
Targeted repairs - One lower-cost alternative is to only rewire high-risk areas like kitchens and places wiring is exposed. However, it does not eliminate the underlying hazards.
-
Insulation alternatives - Special spray foam insulation products are designed to encapsulate knob and tube wiring safely. This reduces, but does not remove, risks.
-
Electrical load management - You can have an electrician install special boxes to prevent overloading circuits and distribute load properly throughout the home.
I recommend consulting with a certified electrician to explore which option is best for your unique home and budget. Living with outdated knob and tube wiring is not worth the serious safety risks it poses for you and your family.