What is Knob-and-Tube Wiring?
Knob-and-tube wiring was an early standardized method of electrical wiring used in buildings in the United States from about 1880 to the 1940s. It consists of insulated copper conductors passing through ceramic knobs and twisting through porcelain tubes, with connections and splices wrapped in cloth insulating tape.
While knob-and-tube wiring was considered very safe when it was introduced, it does not meet modern electrical standards. The outdated materials and installation methods used with knob-and-tube can make it a potential fire hazard. However, many older homes still contain original knob-and-tube wiring behind walls and ceilings.
Why Knob-and-Tube Wiring is Dangerous
There are several factors that make knob-and-tube wiring potentially unsafe:
-
No grounding - There is no ground wire, which protects against shocks and allows faults to be detected. This violates modern electrical code.
-
Insulation breakdown - The cloth and rubber insulation ages and cracks over time, exposing live wires. This can lead to arcs, sparks, and fires.
-
Overloading circuits - Knob-and-tube circuits are rated for light loads. Heavier modern appliances can overload the wires and cause overheating.
-
Spliced connections - The loose, cloth-taped connections often fail over time. This results in shorts and potential fires.
-
Exposed wiring - Wires run through joist cavities and can be exposed where insulation has been added or removed. This leads to physical damage.
-
Lack of safety devices - No circuit breakers or fuses are present to interrupt excessive current. Faults can persist unchecked.
While knob-and-tube can function reasonably well if undisturbed, any failures in the old, brittle insulation can have serious consequences. Minor arcs or sparks from damaged wiring can easily start fires inside walls and ceilings.
Signs You May Have Knob-and-Tube Wiring
It can be difficult to determine if a home still contains original knob-and-tube wiring. Some signs that suggest knob-and-tube may still be present include:
-
Two-prong outlets - Lack of three-prong grounded outlets. These may be linked to ungrounded wiring.
-
Wiring in unfinished areas - Ceramic knobs and tubes may be visible in basement ceilings or attic crawl spaces.
-
Wiring wrapped in cloth - Cloth tape wrapped around connections behind outlets or switches.
-
Dimming or flickering lights - Can signal excessive resistance in old circuits.
-
Fuses rather than breakers - Only very old systems still rely on glass cartridge or screw-in fuses.
-
GFCI outlets not working - GFCI outlets may fail to reset or trip due to lack of grounding.
-
Tingle from appliances - Sensation of electric current can indicate lack of grounding.
Having an inspection by a qualified electrician can conclusively determine if knob-and-tube wiring is present. They may also discover other unsafe conditions related to outdated wiring.
Dangers and Risks of Knob-and-Tube Wiring
Knob-and-tube wiring poses a variety of potential risks:
Fire Hazard
Fires are the greatest danger presented by aging, damanged knob-and-tube wiring. Faults in the wiring produce sparks that can easily ignite nearby wood framing, insulation, or debris inside walls and ceilings. Fires often spread undetected in hidden voids.
Shock Hazard
Exposed, damaged wiring can energize surrounding metal fixtures, surfaces, or materials. Coming into contact with these can deliver dangerous electric shocks. Ungrounded knob-and-tube provides no shock protection.
Electrocutions
If faults produce exposed live conductors, it is possible to receive fatal shocks from damaged knob-and-tube wiring, particularly if moisture is present. Even low voltage can cause electrocution under certain conditions.
Equipment Damage
Electrical surges related to damaged, overloaded wiring can destroy sensitive electronic equipment, appliances, and devices. Surges can enter via connected circuits.
Insurance Issues
Many insurers refuse coverage for homes with knob-and-tube, or severely restrict coverage for fire and electrical damage. Lack of grounding and other hazards make claims more likely.
Dangers to Specific Groups
Some groups are at elevated risk from potential knob-and-tube hazards:
-
Homeowners - at risk for fires, property damage, insurance issues, and shock hazards during renovations or wiring access.
-
Children - prone to shocks and burns from contacting exposed wiring while playing.
-
Electricians - risk shocks when servicing faults in old systems. Proper safety procedures are crucial.
-
Firefighters - electrical risks during firefighting operations in homes with knob-and-tube. Can experience shocks from wet wiring.
-
Future renovators - exposed to hazards if wiring is hidden and not identified during future work. Creates unexpected risks.
-
Tenants and renters - often unaware of wiring condition. Landlords may fail to disclose or address fire and shock risks.
I always take extra precautions when dealing with older homes, as the hazards to me and my family are greatly elevated if old wiring is present. I advise others to do the same.
Recommendations for Homes with Knob-and-Tube
If you suspect your home has original knob-and-tube wiring, I strongly recommend the following:
-
Have a professional evaluation by a licensed electrician to identify all wiring. They can provide repair or replacement options.
-
Consider a full replacement of knob-and-tube wiring for maximum safety. I replaced mine even though it was very costly.
-
At minimum, have the wiring overhauled. Remove cloth insulation, improve splices, and add GFCI protection.
-
Add new overcurrent protection like circuit breakers. Avoid overloading circuits.
-
Leave knob-and-tube undisturbed. Do not conceal it behind new insulation or walls.
-
Improve electrical safety by adding tamper-resistant outlets, arc-fault breakers. Install smoke alarms.
-
Disclose the presence of old wiring to any potential buyers if selling the home.
Replacing knob-and-tube wiring will be expensive, but is worthwhile considering the potential risks. I advise all homeowners to take steps to ensure their home's electrical safety. Hidden electrical fires are devastating.
Conclusion
Knob-and-tube wiring, while once considered very safe, does not meet modern safety standards and can pose serious fire and shock hazards due to its age, lack of grounding, and outdated materials. Homeowners with old internal wiring may be at risk. There are often few signs of its presence. I highly recommend having a professional inspection and considering upgrades or replacement for this forgotten wiring system if found in your home. Taking action to identify and address electrical risks is essential to protect your home and family.