What is Knob-and-Tube Wiring?
Knob-and-tube wiring was an early standardized method of electrical wiring used in buildings in the United States from about 1880 to the 1940s. It consists of insulated copper conductors running through ceramic knobs and tubes, which provide protection and structural support.
Key features:
- Wires - Single copper conductors with cloth or rubber insulation
- Knobs - Porcelain or glass knobs to separate and support the wires
- Tubes - Porcelain tubes to protect wires where they pass through walls and floors
- No ground wire - Knob-and-tube systems did not include a ground wire
This old wiring system has largely been forgotten as most homes have transitioned to modern wiring methods. However, some older homes still have remnants of knob-and-tube wiring, which poses some risks but also some surprising benefits.
Why Knob-and-Tube Wiring Was Used
Knob-and-tube wiring became the standard electrical wiring method in the late 19th century. It offered important advantages over earlier wiring methods:
- Safety - The wiring was totally enclosed and insulated, reducing fire risks.
- Expandability - The simple components allowed wires to be added easily.
- Air circulation - Space between wires prevented overheating.
The knob-and-tube system continued to be installed into the 1930s, even as new wiring methods emerged. The components were simple and reliable, though labor-intensive to install.
By the 1940s, knob-and-tube wiring was obsolete as new systems like armored cable offered more capabilities. However, the old wiring remains in many old houses.
Dangers and Downsides of Knob-and-Tube Wiring
While knob-and-tube wiring was safe when installed correctly, it does pose some risks in older homes:
- Fire hazard - Insulation can degrade over time, exposing bare wires. This can lead to short circuits and fires.
- Shock hazard - No grounding wire means no ground fault protection. Faults can energize metal surfaces.
- Overload - Systems were designed for lower electrical loads. Today's loads can overheat the wiring.
- Insurance issues - Many insurers won't cover houses with knob-and-tube wiring due to fire risks.
- Resale value - Home buyers are often scared off by the old wiring, meaning lower offers.
These risks are very real in deteriorated, modified, or overloaded knob-and-tube systems. However, well-maintained, undisturbed knob-and-tube wiring can often still be safe and serviceable.
Surprising Benefits of Knob-and-Tube Wiring
While knob-and-tube wiring can certainly be dangerous, maintained systems also have some surprising benefits:
-
Higher copper content - Knob-and-tube wires typically have a higher copper content than modern wires. This means lower resistance and less voltage drop.
-
No aluminum wiring - Knob-and-tube systems avoided the problematic aluminum wiring used in some houses in the 1960s and 70s.
-
Open air design - The air circulation between wires prevents insulation breakdown from heat.
-
Easy to modify correctly - The simple components allow qualified electricians to modify and expand knob-and-tube systems safely.
-
Often still code-compliant - Well-maintained knob-and-tube systems often still meet electrical code requirements for existing installations.
-
Historical accuracy - Preserving knob-and-tube wiring maintains the historic integrity of older homes.
So while knob-and-tube wiring should never be used for new installations, maintained vintage systems can sometimes be superior to modern wiring in durability and safety.
Protecting Myself With Knob-and-Tube Wiring
As the owner of a home with knob-and-tube wiring, I take specific precautions to protect myself:
-
I had the system thoroughly inspected by an electrician familiar with knob-and-tube. This identified any risks.
-
I avoid overloading circuits or installing high-draw appliances on knob-and-tube circuits.
-
I carefully limit any insulation in areas around knob-and-tube to prevent overheating.
-
I have GFCI outlets installed on ungrounded knob-and-tube circuits to protect against shocks.
-
I check for any damaged or deteriorated wiring and have repairs made immediately.
-
I never attempt to modify or expand the system myself - only knowledgeable professionals.
-
I confirmed my insurance coverage based on my home's specific knob-and-tube system.
While upgrading the wiring would provide greater safety, I have chosen to preserve this bit of history. With proper diligence and maintenance, the well-installed knob-and-tube system in my old home remains safe, serviceable, and able to protect me.
Conclusion
Knob-and-tube wiring reminds us of an earlier era of electrical work, before home circuits became complex and lighting became abundant. While obsolete for new installations, well-maintained vintage knob-and-tube systems can still be safe and reliable when properly inspected and cared for. With attention and caution, the forgotten knob-and-tube could perhaps save my home from electrical hazards, just as it did decades ago.