I first learned about knob and tube wiring when I bought my 1910s craftsman house. Upon inspection, the electrician told me the wiring was original knob and tube and would need to be replaced to meet modern electrical codes. This started my journey into understanding this important but often overlooked part of electrical history.
What is Knob and Tube Wiring?
Knob and tube (K&T) is an early method of electrical wiring used in buildings from about 1880 to the 1940s. It consists of insulated copper conductors passing through ceramic knobs to provide air space and prevent contact with framing members. The wires are supported along their length by porcelain tubes.
This primitive system eventually sparked the widespread adoption of electricity in buildings. While revolutionary for its time, knob and tube has been banned in most areas due to safety concerns. However, some of this original wiring still exists in older homes today.
The Rise of Knob and Tube Wiring
In the late 1800s, electricity was just beginning to be adopted for lighting in buildings. The arc lighting systems used at the time were impractical and even dangerous for home use.
Around 1880, Thomas Edison began marketing his incandescent lightbulb for indoor use. This created huge demand for a safe and effective way of running wiring through buildings to power these newfangled electric lights.
Knob and tube wiring was the solution. It was developed to prevent fire and shock hazards associated with early electrical systems. The knobs and tubes provided open air space between conductors and wood framing, reducing risk of short circuits and overheating.
By separating wires into individual ceramic knobs and tubes, knob and tube allowed electrical wiring to be run safely through wooden structures. This simple but ingenious system sparked the widespread adoption of electricity in homes and businesses.
How Knob and Tube Wiring Works
The knob and tube system consists of individual copper wires coated with rubber or cloth insulation. The insulated wires are supported by porcelain knobs attached to framing members and run through porcelain tubes where they pass through joist and stud spaces:
-
Ceramic knobs - Wires are attached to ceramic knobs spaced along the path of the wire run. The knobs hold the wires away from any wood framing to prevent overheating and fire.
-
Porcelain tubes - Where wires pass through open spaces between walls and ceilings, they are threaded through porcelain tubes for protection and support.
-
Insulated wires - The copper wires themselves are insulated with rubber or cloth wrap. This prevents wires from touching each other or grounded metal objects like piping.
This clever spacing and insulation of conductors allowed electrical wiring to be installed safely in wood-frame buildings for the first time.
The Rise of Electrical Adoption
Knob and tube wiring sparked the rapid adoption of electricity across America:
-
Allowed indoor lighting - The knob and tube system enabled safe, in-home electric lighting using Edison's new incandescent bulbs. No longer just for lighting streets and public spaces, electricity could now be used practically in homes and businesses.
-
Fueled home appliances - As more homes were wired for lighting, the electricity infrastructure enabled adoption of electric appliances like irons, toasters, washing machines, and fans. By 1920, electricity was powering major home appliances.
-
Supported industrial growth - Factories with knob and tube wiring installed electric motors, machines, and lighting. This drove productivity gains and economic growth during the Industrial Revolution.
Overall, knob and tube wiring acted as a catalyst that pushed America into the electrical age. Within just 40 years, electricity went from a novelty to an essential necessity of modern life.
The Demise of Knob and Tube Wiring
By the 1930s, knob and tube wiring was rendered obsolete by improvements in electrical systems:
-
Nonmetallic sheathed cable - In the 1920s, a new type of electrical wiring emerged with insulated wires bundled in a flexible fiber sheath. Unlike knob and tube, it could be installed in existing walls easily.
-
Metal conduit wiring - Rigid metal conduits started replacing porcelain tubes for wire protection. This provided more durability and allowed complete replacement of knob and tube systems.
-
Safety concerns - As electrical demand grew, the primitive knob and tube wiring proved insufficient. Lack of grounding wires and overloading circuits raised fire and shock risks.
-
Increasing regulation - By the 1930s, stricter electrical codes emerged governing wiring methods, capacity, and safety. Knob and tube installations fell far short of the new standards.
By the 1950s knob and tube was obsolete and prohibited for new construction. However, the simple wiring system had already acted as a catalyst to usher in the Electrical Age.
Dangers of Old Knob and Tube Wiring Today
Although knob and tube sparked the adoption of electricity, it is now considered outdated and dangerous by modern standards:
-
Insulation deterioration - The old rubber and cloth insulation often breaks down over time, exposing bare live wires. This creates serious shock and fire hazards.
-
Lack of grounding - Knob and tube has no equipment grounding conductor. Ungrounded systems are more vulnerable towiring issues and lightning strikes.
-
Overloaded circuits - The wiring was designed for basic early 20th century electricity needs. Today's power demands can easily overload the system.
-
Difficult to inspect - It is hard to thoroughly inspect knob and tube wiring because much of it is hidden behind walls and ceilings. Problems can go undetected.
-
Fire risk - The open wiring method leaves conductors more susceptible to damage. This can lead to arcing, sparks, and fires.
For these important safety reasons, knob and tube wiring is prohibited by electrical codes in most areas today. Any existing old K&T systems should be properly updated or replaced.
My Experience Replacing Knob and Tube Wiring
When I discovered the knob and tube wiring in my century home, I knew it needed to be addressed. As an engineer, I found the system fascinating but realized it posed safety risks. Here is how I went about replacing it:
-
I hired a qualified electrician to carry out the work safely and legally. They handled obtaining necessary permits.
-
We developed a step-by-step plan for the replacement process that minimized disruption to the home.
-
The electrician walked me through the whole rewiring project to help me understand what was being done.
-
We took care to fish new wires through walls and ceilings in the least invasive manner possible.
-
I opted to rewire the whole house rather than just piecemeal. This ensured that everything was brought fully up to modern safety standards.
-
The project took about two weeks and cost around $8,000 in total. This provided great peace of mind knowing my family was no longer relying on obsolete and dangerous knob and tube wiring.
While costly, I highly recommend fully updating old wiring. The safety benefits are invaluable for both protecting your family and preventing catastrophic electrical fires.
The Knob and Tube Wiring Legacy
While prohibited today, knob and tube wiring holds an important place in the history of electrification. This simple wiring method enabled the practical and safe use of electricity in buildings for the first time.
By allowing electrical lighting, knob and tube wiring acted as a catalyst for the adoption of electricity across America in the late 1800s and early 1900s. This primitive system powered the lighting revolution and helped usher in the age of electrical appliances.
So while the knob and tube wiring itself was short-lived, its impact was immense. This overlooked wiring system paved the way for the Electrical Age and modern society as we know it today.