How to Remove Fossil Fuel Subsidies and Level the Energy Playing Field

What are fossil fuel subsidies?

Fossil fuel subsidies are government incentives given to the fossil fuel industry to lower their costs of production and boost their profitability. These incentives include direct cash transfers, tax breaks, loan guarantees, price controls, and more. Fossil fuel subsidies artificially reduce the price of oil, coal, and natural gas, which incentivizes more production and consumption. This leads to negative impacts like more greenhouse gas emissions, inefficient energy markets, and foregone opportunities to transition to clean energy. Globally, fossil fuel subsidies amount to hundreds of billions of dollars per year.

Why fossil fuel subsidies are harmful

Fossil fuel subsidies are extremely harmful for several key reasons:

• Increased emissions: Subsidies encourage more fossil fuel production and consumption, resulting in higher greenhouse gas emissions that drive climate change. This directly undermines efforts to curb emissions and transition to clean energy.

• Market distortions: Subsidies distort free market dynamics, leading to overproduction of fossil fuels beyond what is economically efficient. This crowds out investment in renewable energy sources.

• Regressive impacts: Subsidies disproportionately benefit fossil fuel producers and high-income consumers. Lower income groups see fewer benefits, despite paying for subsidies through taxes.

• Foregone government revenue: Subsidies represent foregone tax revenue that could be invested in healthcare, education, infrastructure, and other public priorities.

• Encourage resource waste: Subsidized low prices encourage overconsumption and inefficient use of finite resources like oil and gas. This risks resource depletion and energy shortages in the future.

How fossil fuel subsidies impact the energy playing field

Fossil fuel subsidies heavily tilt the energy playing field against renewable sources like solar, wind, geothermal, and more:

• Subsidized fossil fuel prices make renewables less cost competitive. This is despite renewables becoming cheaper than fossil fuels in many instances.

• Subsidies reduce investor confidence in renewables since distorted fossil fuel prices create an uneven playing field.

• Subsidies divert capital away from renewables towards overly inflated fossil fuel projects.

• Artificially inexpensive fossil fuels depress technological innovation in renewables due to reduced competitiveness.

• State owned fossil fuel companies in many countries crowd out private investment in clean energy.

This uneven playing field results in suboptimal societal outcomes since it hampers the transition to sustainable energy usage.

Steps governments can take to remove fossil fuel subsidies

Phasing out fossil fuel subsidies will not be easy, but governments have several options:

Implement gradual phase-out plans

• Set multi-year subsidy reduction targets e.g. 10% per year over 5 years.
• Communicate plans clearly to industry and the public.
• Pair phase-outs with targeted assistance for low-income groups.

Swap subsidies for incentives to adopt clean energy

• Redirect fossil fuel subsidies into solar, wind, EV incentives.
• Offer low interest loans for renewable energy projects.
• Fund retraining programs for fossil fuel workers to learn new skills.

Pass fossil fuel subsidy reform legislation

• New laws can repeal specific subsidies or set phase-out timelines.
• Reform fossil fuel royalty rates and production contracts.
• Close tax code loopholes benefiting fossil fuel companies.

Overhaul fossil fuel taxation

• Implement carbon pricing schemes via carbon taxes or cap-and-trade systems.
• Raise excise taxes on transport and heating fuels.
• Impose stricter royalties on fossil fuel extraction.

Increase transparency about subsidies

• Publish detailed subsidy data and economic impact assessments.
• Conduct regular audits of fossil fuel subsidies.
• Disclose fossil fuel lobbying efforts and associated funding.

Examples of successful fossil fuel subsidy reforms

Some countries have made promising strides in removing subsidies:

• Indonesia completely eliminated gasoline and diesel subsidies by 2015 after 12 years of incremental reforms.

• India deregulated diesel prices in 2014 and continues reforming natural gas and coal subsidies.

• Germany and Sweden restructured coal mining sector incentives in line with EU policies to phase out subsidies.

• Argentina passed wide-ranging reforms to subsidies in 2018 including taxes on oil exports and reduced electricity subsidies.

• United States ended tax breaks for fossil fuel exploration through the Inflation Reduction Act passed in 2022.

While more work remains, these examples demonstrate that with proper planning and policy design, phasing out fossil fuel subsidies is achievable.

The benefits of ending subsidies

Phasing out fossil fuel subsidies will deliver multiple economic, social, and environmental benefits:

• Reduced greenhouse gas emissions helping meet Paris Agreement goals.

• Cleaner air leading to lower respiratory illnesses and deaths.

• Leveled energy playing field unlocking investment into renewable sources.

• Trillions in increased government revenue for healthcare, education, infrastructure.

• More sustainable long-term energy supply as dependence on finite resources is reduced.

• Technological innovation towards cheaper clean energy solutions.

• Fairer distribution of energy costs rather than disproportionate benefits to fossil fuel producers.

Removal of subsidies will lead to short-term costs, particularly for fossil fuel-dependent sectors. But this short-term pain will enable massive long-term gains across public health, environmental sustainability, climate change mitigation, and energy access and affordability.

In summary, phasing out fossil fuel subsidies requires comprehensive but gradual reforms across taxation, legislation, transparency, and monitoring. With strong policy design and communication, subsidy reform can tilt the energy playing field towards renewables while unlocking social, economic, and environmental benefits. The opportunities are ripe for governments worldwide to act now and phase out subsidies that not only harm their citizens but endanger the entire planet.