Knob and tube wiring was commonly installed in homes built before 1950. While it served its purpose at the time, this outdated wiring can be a fire hazard and isn't sufficient for modern electrical loads. Replacing it usually requires extensive demolition to access the wiring in walls and ceilings. However, there are techniques that allow knob and tube wiring to be replaced with minimal destruction to your home.
What Is Knob and Tube Wiring?
Knob and tube wiring consists of individual wires that are run through open spaces and secured with porcelain knobs. They are not bundled together like modern Romex cable. The wires are separated from each other and surrounded by air for insulation. While this was suitable at the time, it does not meet modern electrical standards.
The main problems with knob and tube wiring are:
-
Fire hazard - The old, brittle insulation can crack and expose bare wires. This creates a serious fire risk.
-
Insufficient for modern loads - Homes today have more electrical devices and demand more power. Knob and tube wasn't designed for this.
-
No ground wire - There is no equipment ground, which is essential for safety.
Why Replacing Knob and Tube Wiring Is Challenging
Replacing knob and tube wiring the traditional way requires cutting open walls, ceilings, and floors to access the old wiring. This involves extensive demolition and repair work to:
- Cut openings to trace wiring paths.
- Remove plaster or wall materials to expose wires.
- Remove knob and tube wires.
- Install new wiring in its place.
- Patch, repair, paint, and refinish all wall surfaces.
This process is highly invasive, time-consuming, messy, and expensive. Homeowners usually want to avoid this demolition headache.
Secret Techniques to Reroute Wiring Without Wall Damage
There are several techniques electricians can use to replace knob and tube wiring without ripping open walls:
1. Lifting Ground Floor Boards
For homes with crawl spaces or basements, rerouting can often be done by lifting floor boards and accessing wiring from below.
- The electrician drills small holes into walls/ceilings to locate existing wires.
- New wires are attached and pulled up into the walls from below.
- The old knob and tube is disconnected and left dormant.
This avoids opening up walls from the inside. Floor access holes are easy to cover up afterwards.
2. Fishing New Wires Alongside Old Ones
Electricians can "fish" new wiring by attaching it to the old and pulling both through the walls at once.
- Holes are drilled to locate the existing knob and tube path.
- New wires are tied to the old and pulled through the walls together.
- The knob and tube is disconnected and left in place.
This uses the old wiring like a guide rope to pull new wires through without major demolition.
3. Snaking Flexible Wiring Through Wall Cavities
Instead of rigid Romex, flexible armored cable can be snaked alongside old knob and tube wiring:
- Small access holes are cut into walls.
- Flexible metal-clad cable is fed through and follows the existing path.
- Old wiring is disconnected when done.
This flexible cable can easily bend and maneuver around obstacles inside walls.
Key Planning Steps to Minimize Wall Damage
Careful planning is crucial for replacing knob and tube wiring with minimal invasion:
-
Thoroughly map out the existing wiring through visual inspection and tapping walls. Understanding the full knob and tube path is vital.
-
Determine best access points for lifting floors or cutting small holes to reach wiring runs.
-
Choose wiring method - Romex, flexible cable, etc. - that will work best for each run.
-
Develop detailed step-by-step plan to remove old wiring and install new, starting at outlets and fixtures then working back to the panel.
Proper planning will allow the electrician to strategically access wiring through discreet openings and replace it efficiently with minimal destruction.
Is It Worth Trying to Save Your Walls?
Replacing knob and tube wiring without tearing down walls requires extra planning, time, and expertise. Is it worth the effort compared to a total rewire?
Consider the pros and cons:
Pros of Minimally Invasive Knob and Tube Replacement:
- Avoid demolition mess and repairs
- Preserve home aesthetics and architecture
- Take less time compared to rewiring from scratch
- Cost savings on wall materials and labor
Cons to Consider:
- Requires careful planning and electrical expertise
- More difficult to thoroughly inspect wiring throughout
- sections of old wiring may remain if inaccessible
- Potential for hidden expenses if issues emerge
In summary, it makes sense to attempt minimally invasive rewiring on a case-by-case basis. Homeowners should carefully consider their specific situation. For severely outdated wiring, exposed knob and tube, or insufficient electrical capacity, a full rewire might be better.
Conclusion: Minimally Invasive Replacement Is Achievable
Replacing outdated, hazardous knob and tube wiring without opening up walls is possible in many cases. The secret is having an experienced electrician assess your specific wiring situation and develop a tailored plan using wiring access techniques. With proper planning and skill, the headaches of demolition can be avoided. Addressing fire risks and electrical deficiencies can be done discreetly and efficiently.
While minimally invasive replacement has advantages, it requires thoughtful planning and expertise. Homeowners should carefully weigh their options. With the right electrician and plan, knob and tube wiring can be brought up to modern safety standards without destroying your walls.