Knob and tube wiring was once the gold standard for electrical systems, but over time it has proven to be outdated and dangerous. As a homeowner, it's important to understand the risks of knob and tube wiring and why it's best to fully replace it.
A Brief History of Knob and Tube Wiring
Knob and tube wiring was commonly installed in homes built prior to 1930. It features insulated wires that are run through ceramic knobs attached to framing studs, and through porcelain tubes through walls and ceilings.
At the time, knob and tube was an excellent system - the thick rubber insulation minimized fire risk. It was perfectly adequate for the limited number of electrical devices found in early 20th century homes.
By the 1950s and 60s however, knob and tube began to pose risks as electricity needs increased. Yet many homes today still rely on antiquated and dangerous knob and tube systems.
The Overlooked Dangers of Knob and Tube Wiring
While once considered safe, knob and tube wiring poses a number of hazards to modern homes:
-
Fire risk - the old, cracked insulation can expose bare wires to combustible materials in walls and attics. Faulty connections and spliced wires also increase fire risk.
-
Insufficient capacity - knob and tube wiring lacks the capacity to handle the electricity needs of modern homes. Overloaded circuits can overheat and spark fires.
-
Shock hazard - degraded insulation exposes bare wires, increasing risk of shocks or electrocution.
-
Appliance incompatibility - most modern appliances cannot safely connect to ungrounded, two-prong knob and tube systems.
-
Insurance issues - many insurers won't issue policies for homes with knob and tube wiring, or charge significantly higher premiums.
-
Lower resale value - knob and tube wiring can deter buyers and lower property values by thousands of dollars.
Yet despite these risks, many homeowners underestimate the dangers of this outdated wiring.
Why Knob and Tube Wiring Must Be Fully Replaced
Some homeowners consider remediation options like splicing knob and tube wires with modern wiring or capping off unused circuits. However, experts agree that the only truly safe option is to completely remove and replace knob and tube wiring.
Here's why full replacement is essential:
-
Partial upgrades leave behind hidden fire and shock risks in walls.
-
Capped wires can become energized from induction.
-
Circuit breakers cannot prevent all overloads and fires.
-
GFCIs don't protect from insulation breakdowns.
-
Splicing in modern wiring creates connection points prone to failure.
-
Insurers often still require full replacement even after partial upgrades.
Ideally, knob and tube wiring should be replaced with grounded copper or aluminum wiring installed to modern electrical codes. This ensures optimal safety and capacity for modern electricity demands.
Finding Contractors Experienced in Knob and Tube Replacement
Full knob and tube rewiring projects require opening up walls and can cost $8,000-$15,000 or more. It's crucial to find experienced professionals.
When evaluating electricians, ask:
-
How many knob and tube replacements have they performed? Look for at least 10-20.
-
Are they licensed, bonded and insured? Do they pull required permits?
-
What are their specific replacement procedures and safeguards?
-
Do they use modern circuit breakers, up to code GFCI outlets, and copper wiring?
-
What disruptions and repairs to walls and finishes will be required?
-
What is the total cost estimate? Get at least 3 bids.
Avoid amateurs - knob and tube requires expertise to remove safely. Take time to find the right contractor.
Is it Worth the Investment?
Some homeowners put off knob and tube replacement due to the considerable cost. However, it's an investment that quickly pays for itself in safety and peace of mind.
Consider that a wiring fire can cost tens or hundreds of thousands in repairs. And remember, money can’t replace lost memories or ancestral possessions damaged in a fire.
Replacement also increases your home’s value and makes selling easier. This means you’ll recoup much of the project costs.
Finally, the security of knowing your home's electrical system is completely modern and safe is priceless.
Don't Delay - Get Your Knob and Tube Wiring Replaced
Knob and tube wiring has reached the end of its lifespan. Don't risk safety any longer - schedule an evaluation and get quotes from experienced electricians. The investment is well worth it.
With outdated and dangerous knob and tube wiring, it's not a matter of if you'll have problems, but when. Full replacement is the only option to protect your home, family and belongings.